Checklist for the Offering of Reasons: Consideration of Objections to your Arguments After offering reasons for accepting your view, you need to consider objections. In DVC, Our ethical obligations are not creations of society nor are they requirements of logic.
Obligations Arising From Sentiments Making an ethical argument while using this definition of ethical is probably the easiest and simplest way to make an ethical argument. What makes for logical organization?
Be prepared for the possibility that people who disagree with you may claim that the action which you are claiming is unethical is actually beneficial to human well-being; likewise, they might claim that an action you are supporting as ethical is detrimental to human well-being. Likewise, when we see someone who is very happy, we sympathize with that happiness.
For example, if you were arguing that action X is unethical, you might say that humans share the strong ethical intuition that dishonesty is wrong, and would then go on to show how action X is dishonest. First, there are objections that are directed against the reasons that you have offered in support of your thesis, and which claim, therefore, either that some of your assumptions are implausible, or that some of your reasoning is unsatisfactory.
A Non-Religious, Philosophical Approach Many people defend ethical views by appealing either to religious or theological assumptions, or to moral principles that are religiously based.
Basically though, the idea is to avoid making assumptions that very few or no reasonable people would make. Have I developed my argument in a full and detailed way, so that all of my reasoning is clear to the reader? Obscurity is not a sign of profundity. Why would someone disagree with each of these points?
This advice may seem vague, but perhaps this is unavoidable.
For example, if action X is unethical in the mind-independent sense, then that action would be ethically wrong regardless of what anyone thought about it. In that case, you might want to assume the existence of God in your opening paragraph instead of spending several pages providing an argument for the existence of God.
Nagel then asks his reader to ask themselves the following question: If we think it would be wrong for someone to rob us, we must acknowledge that it would be wrong for us to rob another person. For example, if you were writing a thesis on ethics, it would probably be unwise to make many assumptions, if any.
The Offering of Reasons for your View After setting out your thesis, and outlining your overall approach in the introductory paragraph, you need to have a section in which you offer reasons for accepting the view that you are advancing. Have I responded carefully to that objection?
Are the sections divided into appropriate subsections?Whenever you consider an ethical argument, you are likely to have your own intuitions about the moral issue at stake. It might be your A Guide to Writing in Ethical Reasoning 15| page 3 Such alternative answers can appear in your essay as counterarguments.
Each time you address a counterargument, your thesis becomes more plausible. The argument paper would go further, suggesting specific ways that a recycling program should be adopted and utilized in that particular area.
To write an argument essay, you’ll need to gather evidence and present a well-reasoned argument on a debatable issue. Your essay should be a position paper, not a report. The paper must make an ethical argument in defense of a thesis. It doesn’t matter what thesis you defend, but the argument must be clear and coherent.
Essays covering interesting ethical topics are often assigned to students, and this list of potential topics was designed for students. These topics and subtopics might inspire you when writing your next essay, position paper, or speech.
Courage can come in subtle forms, and that can include. Writing an Ethical Argument This document is intended to be an instructional resource for students or instructors who want to learn more about how to write an ethical argument.
This document is divided into four sections, each of which discusses. Thirdly, for each of the arguments that you'll be discussing, write down, on another filing card, the basic structure of that argument. Finally, re-examine everything that you have written down.
Can you see a more effective way of .Download